Who Looked Hotter: Eva or Scarlett?

December 17th, 2008 by Evil Beet


eva_scarlett1

eva_scarlett2

At the LA premiere of The Spirit on Wednesday night.


Before you leave a comment, please make sure you've read our Guide to Commenting. It could save you a great deal of embarrassment.

47 Responses to “Who Looked Hotter: Eva or Scarlett?”

  1. Loveitloveit says:

    surprisingly…eva :)

  2. thatLisa says:

    Eva. She is so hot. Scar Jo is blah

  3. Poozy says:

    Eva. She’s annoying, but Scarlett’s worse. Also, what’s with that hemline? Scarlett looks matronly and smug. She is the smuggest and matronliest.

  4. Eggle says:

    Eva. Scarlett looks like a little girl.

  5. c. says:

    i love scarjo, but this one goes to eva. scarlett needs to hide them horse hoofs better

  6. Heatherlyisaverb says:

    maybe they should have swapped dresses…….?

  7. Mercedes says:

    Eva, no doubt about it.

  8. HoLy says:

    SCARLETT OF COURSE!
    She’s so beautiful :D
    Eva Mendes doesn’t look good at all there…

  9. Tracy says:

    Eva. But I’m biased because I think Scarlett is FUG.

  10. Chelsea says:

    Up close Scarlett looks better but from far away Eva totally wins. Scarlett needs a new dress.

    • Charlotte says:

      I totally agree with you, Head shot of scarlette is much more attractive then evas, but from a distance is has to be eva

  11. Grace says:

    Eva, even though her shoulders are up around her ears somewhere. ScarJo is awesome, but the cut of that dress isn’t quite as flattering.

  12. tina says:

    eva, she looks more natural.

  13. Khy says:

    Evaaaa<3

  14. Dmarie says:

    Eva is UGLY
    Scarlet looks bad but way better

  15. Co.Cat says:

    Eva.
    But mainly because Scarlett looks like a pig. Like, constantly.

  16. cookie monster says:

    as much as i dislike her and bothers me to admit, Scarlett

  17. Jamie says:

    Eva looks like she is about to walk out on stage as a Miss America contestant…but Scarlett doesn’t look great either…toss up

  18. leo says:

    scarlett!

  19. Liz says:

    is it just me or has scarjo been looking worse and worse lately. her face looks all smashed up, smashed up with UGLY

  20. Lee says:

    Eve by a mile. Scarlett’s dress makes it look as though her boobs were fighting and had to be separated.

  21. Inesita says:

    Scarlett’s dress reminds me of one, JLo was wearing the other day…and I didn’t like that either…I think it looks weird around the boobs…(JLo’s dress: http://evilbeetgossip.film.com/2008/12/16/jennifer-lopez-lands-a-new-movie-role/)

  22. TSS says:

    Seriously… Hohansson is one of the fattest, palest, and bitchiest celebrities I’ve ever seen. She’s got “chubby mamma drama” written all over her.

    How she got Ryan Reynolds is a chubby mystery.

  23. A says:

    When did Eva get so thin?

  24. Persistent Cat says:

    Scarlett is a terrible dresser. Gofugyourself.com has been running pictures of her and Eva at the different premieres and that is actually the best dress of all the ones she wore. It’s like she wants to look dumpy because being sexy is such a curse. Plus she was on the cover of some magazine wearing shorts overalls in an American flag motif. Ew. She’s pretty but she’s a terrible dresser.

  25. dl says:

    no doubt about it- EVA ……. better dress, better body, and i like what she did with her hair.

  26. Eyes of Green says:

    Scarlett looks like she is playing dress up in Mommy’s closet. At a certain age I think women should not wear Princess Barbie dresses.

  27. Cat says:

    I would have to say that both dresses are GORGEOUS on them! But Scarlett’s facial expressions are more elegant and graceful than Eva’s grimacing smile.

  28. PRISCILLA says:

    eva, sheis beautiful and always looks great

  29. Indigo says:

    Eva hands down. Wtf is up with Scarjo’s head?? It looks HUGE!

  30. Just Saying says:

    They are both beautiful women who have avoided anorexia. Two thumbs up!

  31. pair a dimes says:

    both equally as lovely.

    one gossamer and one tropical.

  32. dd says:

    Eva is stunninggggggg and I never got what anyone saw in scarlett

  33. Talia says:

    Scarlett’s face…on Eva’s dress?

  34. grace says:

    eva’s dress is silly even though it looks good, and scarlett looks gorgeous but her dress needs to be longer. i would say eva, except scarlett is soo much prettier

  35. A says:

    eva. scarlet is looking too pale and a bit plump somehow… i think its the color of the dress, the strapless aspect, and what it does around her hips…

  36. jane says:

    i love eva’s dress! scarlet is always wearing the same style of dresses that dont suit her.

  37. kthxbai says:

    Eva looks very exotic, Scarlet looks plain, as always. The Blonde hair made her eyes pop out more and she was prettier, now its just bland and boring.

  38. musicstudent says:

    in pictures eva does nothing for me, i wonder if it would be different in person

  39. Monica says:

    eva all the way

  40. gladys says:

    eva mendes looks like a man , scarlet has the etherial beauty im sick people saying eva hots cause she latin, to me eva se ve como una cara de culo who too high on herself. viva scarlet

  41. Bobo says:

    they´re both ugly:(

Leave a Reply