Jennifer Hudson’s Marrying This?

September 14th, 2008 by Evil Beet


Meet David Otunga, who successfully proposed to Jennifer Hudson on Friday night, her rep confirmed. They’ve been dating for less than a year.

Now, he’s not terrible looking — a little bit of a creep factor, but it could just be a bad picture — and he graduated from Harvard Law, so he’s not a dummy and he certainly has earning potential, but he’s also the same guy who was known as Punk on I Love New York 2.

I don’t have a whole lot of deal-breakers in my dating rulebook, but I’d be pretty wary of going out with a guy who appeared on any ultra-trashy reality dating show. I would be doubly wary of anyone who appeared on that show’s follow-up season.

It’s funny, because if I just heard Jennifer was marrying this buff dude with a Harvard Law degree, I’d be like, “Score, Jen! Totes jealous!” But add in that he appeared on I Love New York 2?

It’s like if someone said, “Listen, Beet. I have the perfect guy for you. He’s tall, he’s hot, he’s buff, he’s smart, he’s loaded, he’s funny, he’s sweet, he’s just amazing!”

I’d be like, “Woah, sounds great, when do I meet him?”

And then they were like, “Well, here’s the catch — and you just let me know if this is a deal-breaker, okay? — he died two months ago. But other than that? He’s ideal. What do you say?”

See, sometimes all it takes is one little piece of information to ruin an otherwise perfect guy.

Congrats, Jen, I guess.


Before you leave a comment, please make sure you've read our Guide to Commenting. It could save you a great deal of embarrassment.

49 Responses to “Jennifer Hudson’s Marrying This?”

  1. Kelsey says:

    Oh…. My…. God

  2. mireee says:

    He looks so, so, so, so, GAY!!

  3. SKF says:

    “Well, here’s the catch — and you just let me know if this is a deal-breaker, okay? — he died two months ago. But other than that? He’s ideal. What do you say?”

    LOL!! That made me literally lol.
    I’m a constant follower of your site’s updates and this is my first time leaving a comment. You’ve a fantastic sense of humour Beet- should definitely consider writing a book sometime! :-)

    xoxo Sarah

  4. Lah-Dee-Dah says:

    BLECH! You are so right…his turn on “I Love New York 2″ negates anything spectacular that he’s done. Oh and mireee is correct. He looks uber-gay. Hudson needs to have a pow-wow with Jones (Star.) I think I’ll go to bed now.

    (Also, Lehman filed Chapter 11 this morning…….sweet dreams America.)

  5. Lindsay says:

    I don’t get the analogy.. not getting to date someone because he died, and judging another because he was on a reality show? i don’t think a bad tv show =’s bad person..?

  6. Looks dodgy, wonder if he has a past in gay porn?

  7. Ugh says:

    Oh, no. I watched him on ILNY…He was actually such a super nice guy on the show and the one that you’re saying the entire time “Why the fuck are you on here???”
    But yeah. I’d be kinda grossed out if I were JH knowing that he at some point had any type of physical contact with New York, real or not.
    And that is a bad pic of him. He wasn’t the most attractive, but his hair never looked….like that.

  8. anon says:

    Can I make a rule? Well, I’m going to anyway. NO ONE is allowed to get engaged after less than a year. There is no reason for it.

  9. Erin says:

    Hey, I’m in my sixth year of marriage to an AMAZING man that I married after dating five months. When you know, you know, I say.

    As for Jen’s man…I see a man boob! He needs a bro (Seinfeld). It’s like…man boob/fat roll…why pose like that? C’mon!!

  10. Chuck says:

    He’s gay.

  11. woohoo says:

    with chuck

  12. Karma says:

    But damn is he pretty ;)

  13. joan says:

    i couldn’t get past the boob, either. i understand bad photos but i also understand destroying them.

  14. momster says:

    Noticed the moob right away, myself. Eww! I hope they will be happy…

    I married my husband after knowing him less than a year…. It’s 12 1/2 years later… I agree w/Erin. When you know, you know.

  15. marissa says:

    dead guy wins over new york alum any day!

  16. Alex says:

    What’s the rush? It’s sad to see how quickly these relationships fall apart.

    Even sadder is the breakup process often results in a period of bad press that lasts longer than the relationship…

  17. wISE oLD lADY says:

    Jennifer:

    Think hard. Star Jones. Terry MacMillian.

    What the word ‘punk’ is nice for?

    Are you getting this? AIDS IS REAL!

  18. TrilCril says:

    He is gross!

  19. meg says:

    Beet, you got it all wrong here. I saw him on I Love New York 2, and he was really sweet and intelligent, and actually seemed like a normal guy, instead of a fame whore. If you watch some clips of the show you’ll see what I mean.

  20. Canaduck says:

    Um…maybe it’s just a lousy picture. He’s probably be pretty attractive if he washed his hair and lost the ridiculous goatee-thing.

  21. quirkygirlkitten says:

    i think in this case the deal breaker is that he is gay.

  22. Anonymous says:

    Not in a million years I would marry this guy!

  23. c. says:

    DON’T DO IT JENNIFER!!!!!! look at what happened when britney married kfed!!!

  24. c. says:

    DON’T DO IT!!!! look at what happened when star jones married al reynolds!!

  25. Dee says:

    I can’t believe it i didn’t know about them. I remember him from that show. He looks real nice but sounds real gay!

  26. allison say: says:

    some of you don’ know what you talking about i think from the ILNY show he seem like a nice guy not{gay}i think he is fineeeeeeee i wish he ask me to married him and why are some of the guy in here saying he look gay you sure you are not the one are gay because it take one to know one all i have to say to jennifer follow your heart and don’t let anyone tell you otherwise

  27. tiffany m: says:

    LOOK JEN YOU HAVE PUT THE BIG GIRLS BACK ON THE MAP!!!!!!!!!!!

    BABY YOU DESERVE SO MUCH MORE HE JUST WANTS TO BE A STAR AND

    IS WILLING TO USE YOU TO GET THERE. IF TIFFANY AKA “NEW YORK”

    TOOK TAYLOR MADE OVER PUNK SHOULD LEAVE YOU THINKING. YOU

    DON’T NEED NEW YORK SLOPPY SECONDS.
    CHOOSE TAYLOR

    MADE OVER PUNK

  28. tiffany m: says:

    WHAT I MEANT WAS YOU DON’T NEED NEW YORKS SLOPPY SECOND.

    PUNK WAS HIS NICK NAME. HE IS AS GAY AS A THREE DOLLAR BILL.

  29. Chuck says:

    Allison,

    He is gay. Take the blinders off. Are you not aware of what Star Jones has gone through when she married her gay boyfriend?

  30. Mama i says:

    If you are going to marry him take a little longer to get to know him and yourself in this relationship. If you go in go slowly, slowly, slowly. If your’re gonna get out get out quick.

  31. Ms. Realistic says:

    Jen know one can tell you who to love. But! listen to what people are thinking and saying. Remember, something that smells like roses aren’t roses, meaning all of them can be wrong. Take time and know the one you’re with. Young lady you were made for great things. Not to be walked on played with laugh at or disrespected.
    Date him for awhile at least two years or…………get to really know him and what he is about, before you say “I do”. He is looking for fame as a lot of men do, possible not caring who it may hurt. You are just to beautiful to except just anyone, girl go for the gusto!

  32. Ms. Realistic says:

    Jen know one can tell you who to love. But! listen to what people are thinking and saying. Remember, something that smells like roses aren’t roses, meaning all of them can be wrong. Take time and know the one you’re with. Young lady you were made for great things. Not to be walked on played with laugh at or disrespected.
    Date him for awhile at least two years or…………get to really know him and what he is about, before you say “I do”You are just to beautiful to except just anyone, girl go for the gusto!

  33. DEDE says:

    Congrads Hudson… All all need to stop hatin cuz if it was you would date hhim

  34. DEDE says:

    so is he really dead i dint get the joke

  35. ctulip says:

    Oh, my God he is as gay as the day is long…..All that you have worked for is going to be taken away. It always happens when we make the wrong decisions. You are so much better than that….if his history of dating women is ILNY, girl run!! But I do understand the hots, but he definitely is NOT who you need to be marrying or even dating. You’ll always be wondering why the men are flocking and lookin’….it won’t be to you, but to that sweet thang on your arm….

  36. Frederick says:

    Don`t do it….YTou will regret it…. You should have marry that otherr guy you were with…..Stay single…..Until you met you a real man…

  37. CHOCOLATE DIVA 1970 says:

    JENNIFER YOU ARE A BBW WITH AN AMAZING VOICE. GIRL FROM ONE BBW TO ANOTHER THIS DUDE IS 99.99999% GAY. I’VE BEEN MARRIED FOR 9 YRS AND MY HUBBY IS 100% MAN. JUST TEST HIM IN VARIOUS WAYS. TALK TO YOUR GIRLFRIENDS AND FAMILY MEMBERS GET THEIR INPUTS. GOOD LUCK GIRL…….. DON’T LET THE MUSCLES FOOL YA!!!!!!!

  38. SJDixon says:

    I wish them much success! They will both need it

  39. Shelley says:

    Just get a pre-nup and move on!

  40. Minnie says:

    All I have to say is talk to Terry McMillian.

  41. ann says:

    As much as I would love to say congratulation’s are the first thing in order,
    My brown eyed sister, the only think I want you to make sure your attorney does is get you a PRE-nup, and that’s all I want you to promise yourself and your fans. Handle your business gurl…….and yes, he’s fine I watched him. He’ sweet.

    GET THE PRENUP ANYWAY!!!

  42. tee says:

    well, well she taking out the trash. why would she even want to marry what was on tv acting like a jack*** for some one love who still not want him. his family look crazy as hell. boy what a wedding to see soon.

  43. ILoveHimNEWAY!! says:

    OMG, when ILNY was on I FELL IN LOVE with this man!!! I don’t care what ANYBODY say’s about him, he DOES NOT look GAY, he was EXTREMELY polite, Not Groping all over nasty ass New York. I think the man went on there TRYING to find love, o.k. so it was N.Y (yuck) but you could tell we was SINCERE! and as N.Y said, “when we were in Miami, he never made a move on me” Hmmm maybe cuz she is a trampy azz, washed up, ghetto azz HOOD RAT???? Ya think??
    YOU GO Jen! And if you decide YOU don’t want him…..send his FINE AZZ MY WAY!!!! Man Boob or NOT! I think he’s so so sexy!!!!

  44. Nina says:

    Why are you guys hatin I saw him on ILNY and he was really sweet. Just because he is a sweet guy doesn’t automatically make him gay. I also want to say sorry for your loss Jen, its real sad when you lose a loved one let a lone two.

  45. shut your pie holes…he’s hot

  46. Princess says:

    This marriage will not last. It sounds put together. Definitely not a marriage of love. I hope Jennifer learns how to respect and love other people more. From i have read about her, seems she is very disrespectful and ungrateful. She is a phony too.

  47. ERICKA says:

    IM SO HAPPY FOR THEN I LOVE JENNIFER AND PUNK

  48. ERICKA says:

    i know im too young but i wish i had PUNK! LOL

  49. mary says:

    jen are you crazzy and foolish hes going to use you

    to get fame and money from your sucessfull career

    please don”t be a dumb fool.

Leave a Reply