Jamie-Lynn Sigler and Vanessa Minnillo: Love It or Leave It

August 27th, 2008 by Evil Beet


Both these looks are worthy of discussion.

At the launch of Tide and Downy Total Care in NYC. Yeah. They walked the red carpet for a detergent. Either Tide has an awesome PR firm or these girls are really desperate for invites.


Before you leave a comment, please make sure you've read our Guide to Commenting. It could save you a great deal of embarrassment.

23 Responses to “Jamie-Lynn Sigler and Vanessa Minnillo: Love It or Leave It”

  1. Kelly says:

    I like Jamie-Lynn’s dress, loathe the shoes. Vanessa looks a little bit Junior Prom ‘88 to me.

  2. verbatim says:

    I’m not gonna say it. I’m not gonna say it.

    Ok, I am.

    FIRST!!

    Or perhaps SECOND!! Or even THIRD!! Whoopeedoo my life rocks so much, hah!

    And FINALLY a Jamie-Lynn Sigler post! I love this girl and have missed seeing her around recently. Thanks Beet!

  3. Caz2 says:

    I’d leave it; the colours and nice but I don’t know about the styles, and Jamie-Lynn’s shoes look weird against her bare legs..

  4. Rox says:

    They both look terrible

  5. Windy City Windy says:

    Jamie shouldnt wear the shoes with that dress. and i dont really like her dress to begin with. Post eating disorder girl decides to wear tarp dress? typical.

    Vanessa looks like shes poor and has bad taste.

  6. beetlejuice says:

    OK, those kinda shoes are cute with pants, not dresses, pants people!! Otherwise it just looks like you stuck your feet into the closet in the dark and hoped for the best.

  7. one size fits most says:

    okie off subject here but wth is up with that pit bull energy drink commercial? the song is annoying and it looks small budget…like college.

    anyways. don’t like jamie’s dress and she wore the wrong shoes with it. for van’s dress…maybe if she switched the top half with the bottom half it might be less prom like and more red carpet style? but they’re both just ehhhhhhhhhh.

  8. mimi in mo says:

    I agree with what Kelly said & I think that ‘these girls are really desperate for invites’.

  9. mali says:

    vanessa ALWAYS looks like she going to the prom, she needs an intervention

  10. princess pink says:

    likes: jamie’s-lynn’s dress

    dislikes: everything else. especially jamie-lynn’s shoes.

  11. princess pink says:

    make that:
    jamie-lynn’s dress*

  12. adair says:

    the colors are nice, but I don’t think either dress is right for the person wearing it.

  13. elle says:

    leave them both.
    the one on the left looks like a sack and the one on the right looks really old fashioned and satinny cheap. if you know what i mean. colours are ok, nothing special. i want the blue to be a bit more electric blue and the purple to be a bit more deep purple. they’re just so in between.

  14. Red says:

    I bet they got heterosexual stylists!!! or maybe they pissed off their regular stylist? Where do I beging…there’s so much wrong with both outfits…

  15. Stef says:

    Meadow can do no wrong.

  16. .anne. says:

    left: my purplr bedspread
    right: freshman homecoming dress

  17. .anne. says:

    left: my purple bedspread
    right: freshman homecoming dress

  18. Asif. says:

    Is the one on the left wearing SOCKS?!?!?!

  19. Asif. says:

    OH.
    she isn’t.
    my bad ;)

  20. mambaX says:

    I’ve been scrolling up and down
    and trying not to comment
    but…I am unable to
    as a new credited style guru
    I pronounce these two
    fashion disasters

  21. c. says:

    leave it ALLLLL

  22. f. says:

    Jamie-Lynn Sigler’s look would be better if she wasn’t wearing those shoes& Vanessa Minillo’s dress is fugso but the shoes are alright

  23. Anonymous says:

    Jamie is the most pathetic she was on the Sopranos and this is the best she can get? Vanessa at least was in town all week promoting her movie.

Leave a Reply